Tag Archives: double loop

The Agile Planning Onion is Wrong

The concept is simple: there are six levels of planning in an organization, often represented as layers of a metaphorical onion. In the agile planning onion, strategy is the outermost layer. This is meant to indicate that it is the driver of all the planning in the inner layers, which have shorter time horizons, down to the daily planning that occurs in the Daily Scrum or the Daily Standup of the agile teams.

Culture is Missing

The agile planning onion is a reasonable metaphor, but it has a serious limit: culture is missing. Many of you will have heard the quote “Culture eats strategy for lunch [or breakfast]” (attributed to quite a number of different people – I’m not going to sort out who was the original). How do we represent culture on the onion? Is it a seventh layer on the outside? Maybe, but for most organizations, culture is not planned.

Single Loop Learning

The main problem with the planning onion is that it gives no indication that the planning cycles deal with anything but the product / business side of the work. This implication of single-minded focus gives us permission to limit ourselves to improving our products. This is learning, but it is limited. It is sometimes referred to as “single loop learning”. We make improvements, but never question our underlying beliefs, habits or goals. All improvement (and planning) is within the narrow guard rails of a product mentality.

Double Loop Learning

Culture both surrounds the planning onion, and cuts right through it (nice way to extend the metaphor!) The problem with a visual metaphor that does not include culture is it means that culture remains unconscious. As individuals we might, from time-to-time, find that the organization’s culture clashes with our own expectations, habits or beliefs. But other than this occasional dissonance, we are like onions in dirt – completely unaware of the dirt, yet completely utterly dependent upon it for growth (couldn’t use “fish in water” because that would have introduced a different metaphor – I’m trying for consistency).

In the best agile transformations, individuals, teams and organizations become aware of their culture and consciously work to change it. This is usually due to a strong clash between their current culture, and the behaviors, norms and attitudes of a embryonic agile culture. In Scrum, we find impediments and remove them. In OpenAgile we look for learning about product, process and people. This is, again, roughly speaking, double loop learning… it is learning about learning and applying this to our belief systems, our habits and our attitudes.

Transformation vs. Adoption

Those who share the agile planning onion model, probably don’t realize its limits. I would like to strongly encourage those who use this model to consider re-framing it in terms of culture and organizational learning, rather than planning. I’m terrible at diagrams – I hope someone out there will consider creating a new compelling Agile Learning Onion diagram to show that agile is about Transformation, not merely adoption of planning practices.


Affiliated Promotions:

Try our automated online Scrum coach: Scrum Insight - free scores and basic advice, upgrade to get in-depth insight for your team. It takes between 8 and 11 minutes for each team member to fill in the survey, and your results are available immediately. Try it in your next retrospective.

Please share!
Facebooktwittergoogle_plusredditpinterestlinkedinmailFacebooktwittergoogle_plusredditpinterestlinkedinmail
Berteig
Upcoming Courses
View Full Course Schedule
Real Agility™ Team Performance Coaching with BERTEIG
Online
C$345.00
Oct 28
2021
Details
Advanced Certified Scrum Product Owner® (A-CSPO) [Virtual Learning]
Online
C$1695.00
Oct 29
2021
Details
Real Agility™ Team Performance Coaching with BERTEIG
Online
C$345.00
Nov 1
2021
Details
Real Agility™ Team Performance Coaching with BERTEIG
Online
C$495.00
Nov 1
2021
Details
Real Agility™ Team Performance Coaching with BERTEIG
Online
C$750.00
Nov 2
2021
Details
Real Agility™ Team Performance Coaching with BERTEIG
Online
C$495.00
Nov 3
2021
Details
Certified Scrum Product Owner® (CSPO) [Virtual Learning]
Online
C$1795.00
Nov 4
2021
Details
Scrum Inc Scrum Master and Product Owner® (SSMPO) [Virtual Learning]
Online
C$1995.00
Nov 8
2021
Details
Real Agility™ Team Performance Coaching with BERTEIG
Online
C$345.00
Nov 8
2021
Details
Scrum Master Bootcamp with CSM® (Certified Scrum Master®) [Virtual Learning]
Online
C$1795.00
Nov 9
2021
Details
Certified Scrum Master® (CSM) [Virtual Learning]
Online
C$595.00
Nov 9
2021
Details
Real Agility™ Team Performance Coaching with BERTEIG
Online
C$345.00
Nov 9
2021
Details
Introduction to REALagility™ with ICP® (ICAgile Certified Professional®) [Virtual Learning]
Online
C$695.00
Nov 10
2021
Details
Real Agility™ Team Performance Coaching with BERTEIG
Online
C$495.00
Nov 11
2021
Details
Real Agility™ Team Performance Coaching with BERTEIG
Online
C$495.00
Nov 11
2021
Details
Real Agility™ Team Performance Coaching with BERTEIG
Online
C$495.00
Nov 15
2021
Details
Certified Scrum Product Owner® (CSPO) [Virtual Learning]
Online
C$1795.00
Nov 16
2021
Details
Real Agility™ Team Performance Coaching with BERTEIG
Online
C$345.00
Nov 16
2021
Details
Kanban System Design® (KSD) [Virtual Learning]
Online
C$1795.00
Nov 17
2021
Details
Real Agility™ Team Performance Coaching with BERTEIG
Online
C$345.00
Nov 17
2021
Details
BERTEIG Professional No Agenda Networking [Exclusive Event]
Online
C$0.00
Nov 18
2021
Details
Kanban for Scrum Masters - Improve Your Scrum Mastering Skills
Online
C$149.00
Nov 18
2021
Details
Real Agility™ Team Performance Coaching with BERTEIG
Online
C$495.00
Nov 18
2021
Details
Real Agility™ Team Performance Coaching with BERTEIG
Online
C$750.00
Nov 19
2021
Details
Real Agility™ Team Performance Coaching with BERTEIG
Online
C$345.00
Nov 22
2021
Details
Real Agility™ Team Performance Coaching with BERTEIG
Online
C$495.00
Nov 22
2021
Details
Scrum Master Bootcamp with CSM® (Certified Scrum Master®) [Virtual Learning]
Online
C$1795.00
Nov 23
2021
Details
Certified Scrum Master® (CSM) [Virtual Learning]
Online
C$595.00
Nov 23
2021
Details
Leadership for Managers - How to be an Effective Leader
Online
C$149.00
Nov 23
2021
Details
Real Agility™ Team Performance Coaching with BERTEIG
Online
C$495.00
Nov 24
2021
Details
Certified Scrum Product Owner® (CSPO) [Virtual Learning]
Online
C$1525.75
Nov 25
2021
Details
Real Agility™ Team Performance Coaching with BERTEIG
Online
C$495.00
Nov 29
2021
Details
Team Kanban Practitioner® (TKP) [Virtual Learning]
Online
C$1015.75
Nov 30
2021
Details
Real Agility™ Team Performance Coaching with BERTEIG
Online
C$345.00
Nov 30
2021
Details
Advanced Certified ScrumMaster® (A-CSM) [Virtual Learning]
Online
C$1440.75
Nov 30
2021
Details
Certified Scrum Product Owner® (CSPO) [Virtual Learning]
Online
C$1525.75
Dec 1
2021
Details
Real Agility™ Team Performance Coaching with BERTEIG
Online
C$495.00
Dec 6
2021
Details
Introduction to REALagility™ with ICP® (ICAgile Certified Professional®) [Virtual Learning]
Online
C$1185.75
Dec 8
2021
Details
Real Agility for Managers
Online
C$149.00
Dec 10
2021
Details
ICAgile Certified Professional in Agile Coaching® (ICP-ACC)
Online
C$1995.00
Dec 13
2021
Details
Real Agility™ Team Performance Coaching with BERTEIG
Online
C$495.00
Dec 13
2021
Details
Scrum Master Bootcamp with CSM® (Certified Scrum Master®)
Online
C$1525.75
Dec 14
2021
Details
Certified Scrum Master® (CSM)
Online
C$595.00
Dec 14
2021
Details
Kanban Systems Improvement® (KMPII) [Virtual Learning]
Online
C$1525.75
Dec 14
2021
Details
BERTEIG Professional No Agenda Networking [Exclusive Event]
Online
C$0.00
Dec 16
2021
Details
Certified Scrum Product Owner® (CSPO) [Virtual Learning]
Online
C$1525.75
Dec 16
2021
Details
Kanban for Product Owners - Improve Your Project Ownership Skills
Online
C$149.00
Dec 16
2021
Details
Real Agility™ Team Performance Coaching with BERTEIG
Online
C$495.00
Dec 20
2021
Details
Advanced Certified Scrum Product Owner® (A-CSPO) [Virtual Learning]
Online
C$1440.75
Dec 21
2021
Details
Real Agility for Managers
Online
C$149.00
Dec 22
2021
Details
Kanban for Scrum Masters - Improve Your Scrum Mastering Skills
Online
C$149.00
Jan 6
2022
Details
Practicing Agile Estimation Techniques (ML-PAET)
Online
C$149.00
Jan 6
2022
Details
Real Agility for Managers
Online
C$149.00
Jan 11
2022
Details
Introduction to REALagility™ with ICP® (ICAgile Certified Professional®) [Virtual Learning]
Online
C$1185.75
Jan 12
2022
Details
BERTEIG Professional No Agenda Networking [Exclusive Event]
Online
C$0.00
Jan 20
2022
Details
Real Agility for Managers
Online
C$149.00
Jan 25
2022
Details
ICAgile Certified Professional in Leading With Agility® (ICP-LEA) [Virtual]
Online
C$1865.75
Feb 1
2022
Details
Real Agility for Managers
Online
C$149.00
Feb 8
2022
Details
Kanban for Product Owners - Improve Your Project Ownership Skills
Online
C$149.00
Feb 9
2022
Details
ICAgile Certified Professional in Adaptive Org Design® (ICP-ORG)
Online
C$977.55
Feb 21
2022
Details
Certified Scrum Professional - ScrumMaster® (CSP-SM)
Online
C$1695.75
Feb 24
2022
Details
Real Agility for Managers
Online
C$149.00
Feb 25
2022
Details